Growing up, we always went to Grandma’s house for the holidays. This included usually several generations and was always at her house when they still lived on the ranch. As is typical (I assume) for most people’s holidays, we usually had the same things to eat. Many of those things were pretty much set in stone like the stuffing. No matter if someone wanted to try something new, it had to be “that one”. My kids still feel the same way with some things we make, you don’t change the recipe!
One of the desserts that was always served was Burnt Sugar Pie. It was made by my Great Grandma Goldie, and then later made by my Grandma Sara. Goldie was born in 1895 in Nebraska, and I don’t know if it was from her family, or if it was something that she found later, but everyone loved it.
Great Grandma Goldie Nachtman
Grandma Sara Nachtman
As I grew older and got married, I wanted to make it myself, so I asked them for the recipe. Neither of them had it written down, they just did it the same every year and it worked. With both of them getting older, I thought we had to have it written down, so I went to Grandma’s house one day and Great Grandma came over to show me how to make it, and I wrote down the recipe as they did.
Sadly, they are both gone now, but the Burnt Sugar Pie lives on. In case you want to try it yourself, here is the recipe:
Burnt Sugar Pie
Ingredients
Pie:
3/4 cup Sugar up to 1 cup
2 cups Whole milk (room temperature)
2 ea Egg yolks
1/4 cup Sugar
1/4 cup Cornstarch
1 teaspoon Vanilla
Prebaked pie crust (cooled)
Meringue:
2 ea Egg whites
1/4 cup Sugar
Instructions
Put 3/4-1 cup sugar in cast iron skillet. Cook over med heat until sugar melts and turns golden brown. Stir often and be ready to remove from heat if it gets too dark. You want a nice caramel color. Remove from heat. Add 2 cups milk. Do this carefully, as it will splash when the milk hits the hot sugar. Stir well with a whisk. When the milk hits the sugar, it may (probably will) set up, just keep stirring and it will melt back into the mixture. Meanwhile mix 2 egg yolks, 1/4 cup sugar, 1/4 cup cornstarch & a little milk together.
Add to 1st mixture (slowly) and cook & stir until thick (like pudding) over low-medium heat. Add 1 tsp vanilla. Let mixture cool “some” (to room temp). Pour into baked pie crust.
Meringue:
Beat 2 egg whites until frothy (stiff peaks), add 1/4 cup sugar.
Put on top of pie and bake until lightly browned.